The Last Look…
Posted by Colin Lambert. Last updated: November 17, 2026
There is a lot of noise continuing about potential disruption (of a sort) in the post-trade space, specifically around FX settlement, and the latest findings from the Project Meridian effort will do little to quell that, but how likely is true disruption?
It is probably important to stress that Project Meridian is an experiment and seeks to find out whether one evolutionary path for FX settlement is possible, rather than present that as the only possible route, but the very fact that cross-border synchronisation can work across diverse systems is a positive. Of course, it would be remiss of me not to point out that CLS works across jurisdictions and provides PvP settlement and netting services, and ask the question, exactly how much of an innovation would this be?
The answer is, of course, not much of one – and the report notes how the function of the Synchronisation Operator (SO) would look like something like a clearing house – but that is not the main point to me, because I look at initiatives like Meridian and see them as a potential solution to that huge swathe of the market that is not covered by CLS for various reasons. Were a concept to become reality, it would most likely, initially at least, sit alongside existing mechanisms, rather than replace them.
Looking at the Meridian report, a few things stand out, but again, I am not sure they are new, they are merely focused on a different participant/part of the chain. It notes that there would be operational risk from so much being concentrated in the SO. Naturally there would, but is this just throwing up potential obstacles through an overly-cautious approach? The fact is, there is operational risk surrounding CLS’ ability to function, and that firm puts in a huge effort to ensure the risk is minimised, which is reflected in 25 years without a serious problem (but a couple of close calls!)
The report also notes that what is a “major benefit” in atomic settlement, does not actually, in its truest form, represent settlement finality. This is again correct, but surely is fixed through global coordination, probably through the BIS or one of its peers, and the creation of a regulatory framework for that one system that everyone signs up to. Sound familiar? It should, it is, after all, pretty much how things worked with CLS – we had/have a lead regulator but all jurisdictions with currencies within the system signed up the same set of rules. If someone doesn’t want to sign up to a new system, then don’t let them in – their local markets will suffer soon enough relative to others that are in a “safer” settlement system.
At no stage should we look to weaken the oversight on CLS, it is simply too important to have something go horribly wrong, but that does not mean that the regulatory environment itself cannot change
The report does note that CLS operates on one ledger, whereas an SO would have to work across multiple central bank systems, but that sounds like a technical issue to me, and given how much I hear about how technology is solving everything, it shouldn’t be a heavy lift to get the pieces in place! Again, what is needed, much like with dark pools in trading, is a set of rules accepted by all participants.
If we assume, therefore, that Meridian does have legs, and could potentially offer an avenue to broaden the use of PvP and quicken up settlement times, the bigger question becomes, what of CLS?
I have written before that while it works well and remains a critical infrastructure for the FX markets, CLS does need to be cognisant of the changes taking place in the wider world, especially with so much attention on the potential for DLT in post-trade. It does not have its head in the sand of course, so, to reiterate, I see some form of new mechanism emerging from these projects that will sit alongside CLS. That does not mean, however, that the incumbent should not change. Some of the technical work in these projects could, potentially, be adopted by CLS. Equally, some of the technology itself could be embedded in the firm’s workflows.
The bottom line with CLS is always about the limitations on its growth from its regulatory environment, which is tightly controlled for a very good reason. At no stage should we look to weaken the oversight on CLS, it is simply too important to have something go horribly wrong, but that does not mean that the regulatory environment itself cannot change.
And it is here that the really big change could, at some stage, emerge. If a regulatory/oversight environment is built for a new settlement mechanism, and it works, then it could, potentially be deployed with CLS. If that happens then we do, potentially, get competition in the settlement space, because CLS’ one unassailable differentiator – its oversight regime – is diluted, or removed. In that environment CLS would need to have embraced the broader technological change, because if it does, then it will probably be secure in its position – nobody wants to change too much of a critical function unless they have to, and my view is that as long as it works well, the FX industry will not abandon CLS.
Ultimately then, while Meridian offers a step forward in terms of building out the FX settlement infrastructure, it is unlikely to be a game-changer, but that is OK, because in such a critical function I am not sure we want anything too dramatic. That said, it, and other projects, should serve as a reminder to CLS that it needs to stay abreast of new developments.
There is a tendency in some quarters of the FX industry to shrug at these projects seeking to innovate in the settlement space, mainly, as one such sceptic put it to me recently, “because by the time they get around to building anything you and I will be pushing up daisies”. That is as maybe, but one can’t help but think of Bill Gates’ statement on his time with Microsoft “innovation takes longer than many people expect, but it also tends to be more revolutionary than they imagine”.
Something is going to change here, I am just not sure we know what, and by how much.




